Pirate 1998 Scouting Report - Second Basemen

Last Updated 2 May 1998

On November 17, 1997, Mark Jareb (lshark@AKULA.COM) posted the following to the Pirate e-mail list. I have edited it and included it here with his permission.


Abbreviations are:
-CAL, Calgary, the Bucs AAA team in the
PCL, Pacific Coast League (Nashville replaces Calgary in '98)
-CAR, Carolina, the Bucs AA team in the
SOU, Southern League
-LYN, Lynchburg, the Bucs A+ team in the
CRL, Carolina League
-AUG, Augusta, the Bucs A team in the
SAL, South Atlantic League
-ERI, Erie, the Bucs A- team in the
NYP, New York-Penn League
-GCL refers to the Bucs rookie team in the Gulf Coast League
-DSL refers to the team the Bucs field in the Dominican Summer League. This team is primarily composed of teenagers from the Dominican signed as non-drafted free agents.
Index: | Pirates | Calgary | Carolina | Lynchburg | Augusta | Erie | GCL | Projections |
Pirates
Tony Womack: 28-9/25/69; #7 '91; Guilford College (NC)
2B/SS/OF, L-R, 5-9 155
Womack exceded all expectations in '97 by making the All-Star team and winning the stolen base crown in the NL. However, even with all that, he was slightly below league average offensively for starting 2Bmen. In addition, his defense did not appear to be as good as previously advertised. If you see him play and he gets on base, it becomes immediately apparent why he's overrated; he's very exciting on the base paths and makes a memorable impression. If he could get on base at a better rate, he could be very valuable with his speed; however, that scenario seems very unlikely as he's never shown an ability to draw walks and he's probably maxed his potential BA-wise. He's likely to be the starting 2Bman again in Pittsburgh in '98.
         AB   H  2B 3B HR  BB  SO    BA/OBP/SLG
91 A-   166  46   3  0  1  17  39   277/344/313
92 A    380  93   8  3  0  41  59   245/318/282
93 A+   304  91  11  3  2  13  34   299/328/375
   AA   247  75   7  2  0  17  34   304/348/348
   PIT   24   2   0  0  0   3   3   083/185/083
94 AAA  421  93   9  2  0  19  76   221/255/252
   PIT   12   4   0  0  0   2   3   333/429/333
95 AAA  107  30   3  1  0  12  11   280/353/327
   AA   332  85   9  4  1  19  36   256/296/296
96 AAA  506 151  19 11  1  31  79   298/339/385
   PIT   30  10   3  1  0   6   1   333/459/500
97 PIT  641 178  26  9  6  43 109   278/326/374

Calgary AAA
Tony Beasley: 31-12/5/66; #19 '89 (BAL); Liberty U. (VA)
2B/IF/OF, R-R, 5-8 165
Beasley is a non-prospect. He's a utility infielder who the Bucs have bounced between AAA and AA whenever they needed an extra middle IF. He's had his best years the last two seasons, but I dont see him ever getting a chance at the majors. If the '97 Pirates weren't contending, it may have been a nice gesture to call him up for a little while when the injuries hit. He may be back in '98 in the utility role or he may retire. If he isn't playing, I'd expect to see him coaching somewhere in the low minors.
         AB   H  2B 3B HR  BB  SO    BA/OBP/SLG
'89-'91 in A-, A+, and A+ with BAL
92 A+   237  62  10  2  7  16  44   262/315/409
   AA   158  41   5  3  1   8  33   259/293/348
93 AAA   95  18   3  0  0   4  17   189/235/221
   AA   252  51   7  3  4  23  52   202/268/302
95 AA   335  94  16  4  2  31  44   281/343/370
96 AA   269  84  17  5  4  30  33   312/380/457
97 AAA  220  60   7  5  1  25  23   273/349/364
   AA   117  32   5  0  0   7  16   274/317/316

Kary Bridges: 26-10/27/71; #10 '93 (HOU); U. of Mississipi
2B, L-R, 5-10 165

Acquired from Houston in a 3-way swap of minor leaguers (the Bucs sent Keith Shepherd to the Mets), he could potentially be a decent backup at the major league level. He was considered a prospect in the Astros organization as late as '96. He didn't hit well at New Orleans (AAA) to start the year and was gone. He hits for a high BA, with an average BB rate while having a very low K rate. In short, he's a line drive hitter who puts the ball in play. An excellent guy to have at AAA for insurance. I'm guessing he'll take over Beasley's role as a utility IF, probably at AAA, though a 4th year at AA is not out of the question.
         AB   H  2B 3B HR  BB  SO    BA/OBP/SLG
93 A    263  74   9  0  3  31  18   281/358/350
94 A    447 135  20  4  1  38  29   302/358/371
95 AA   418 126  22  4  3  48  18   301/370/395
96 AA   338 110  12  2  4  32  14   325/382/408
   AAA  140  44   9  1  1   9   8   314/355/414
97 AAA*  64  11   1  2  0   5   9   172/239/250
   AA   283  95  17  1  3   9  10   336/354/435
   AAA*  95  25   4  0  0   7   6   263/314/305
*-the top AAA line is New Orleans and the bottom is Calgary

Carolina AA
Chad Hermansen: 20-9/10/77; #1 '95, Green Valley,NV(HS)
2B (SS/OF), R-R, 6-2 185
Even with Hermansen now moved to 2B, I still rank him as our top position player in the minors. He'll be an excellent offensive player wherever he plays defensively. He'd be above average offensively right now in the majors. He moved from SS because of a high number of errors; primarily, his errors were in throwing the ball. He had similar problems when he moved to CF, though thus far he seems to have handled the late season move to 2B. His hands and range appear to be fine. I'll be curious to see if his Error totals dramatically drop when he leaves Carolina. I don't know how much of a help or hindrance it's been having Tracy Sanders, Ricky Jordan, and Steve Thobe as his 1Bman in Carolina. His defense is the only thing keeping him out of the Pirates starting lineup right now. He's likely to start the year at AAA playing 2B, though it's not out of the realm of possibility that he'll be in Pittsburgh opening day. Regardless, I expect he'll play at least part of '98 in PIT. In the '97 AFL, he put up MVP type offensive numbers. He led the league in hits and set an AFL record for runs scored. Baseball America picked Chad as their #1 prospect in the AFL in 1997. That is quite an honor for a young player among such a talented peer group.
         AB   H  2B 3B HR  BB  SO    BA/OBP/SLG
95  R    92  28  10  1  3   9  19   304/363/533
    A-  165  45   8  3  6  18  39   273/354/467
96  A   226  57  11  3 14  38  65   252/377/513
    A+  251  69  11  3 10  29  56   275/352/467
    HAW 161  41   4  3  2  23  35   255/358/354
97  AA  487 134  31  4 20  69 136   275/373/478
   AFL  179  61  10  4  8  24  52   341/419/575
1997 Scouting Report
Lynchburg A+ (full season, high)
Tony Robinson: 22-6/11/76; #14 '94; Diamond Bar HS (CA)
2B/SS, R-R, 6-0 185
After the '95 season, Baseball America rated Robinson as the best infield glove in the Pirates system. He can be patient at the plate and take a walk, but before this year, he was a poor hitter with virtually no power. Injured in '96 after a month of being overmatched at the plate, he hit much better this past season than anyone would have expected. He began the year at SS in Augusta, then was quickly promoted to Lynchburg when Derek Swafford went on the DL. He remained at 2B when Nunez was promoted to Carolina and has remained the starter even when Swafford came off the DL. He's put himself on the prospect map and likely will be the 2B at AA next year.
         AB   H  2B 3B HR  BB  SO    BA/OBP/SLG
94 GCL  145  29   6  1  0  19  22   200/304/255
95 A    297  68   9  0  2  38  60   229/337/279
96 A+    93  16   3  0  0  17  17   172/313/204
97 A     62  13   4  1  0   5   6   210/286/306
   A+   254  75  16  3  2  28  37   295/377/406

Luis Figueroa: 24-2/16/74; NDFA '97; Berkshire HS (FL)
SS/2B, S-R, 5-9 158

'97 was his first season in organized ball; At Lynchburg he showed the ability to hit for a decent BA, so he's worth keeping an eye on. His relatively low K rate is also a good sign. If Beasley is history (as I expect), Figueroa may start the year at AA. It's more likely, though, that he's the starting 2B at Lynchburg.
         AB   H  2B 3B HR  BB  SO    BA/OBP/SLG
97 A    248  56   8  0  0  35  29   226/322/258
   A+    89  25   5  0  0   7   6   281/333/337

Derek Swafford: 23-1/21/75; #3 '93; Ventura HS (CA)
2B, L-R, 5-10 175

He was a marginal prospect at the beginning of '97, when an injury set him back even further. He began the year at Lynchburg again, hurt himself after a little over a month and then was back at Augusta to finish the season. At the beginning of the year, he really looked like he improved his BB rate, but that didn't hold up at Augusta. His lack of power or low BA may be too great to overcome even if he were to draw BB at such a high rate. He'll probably be back in Lynchburg at 2B but could be out of baseball for '98.
         AB   H  2B 3B HR  BB  SO    BA/OBP/SLG
93 GCL  121  23   1  2  0   4  15   190/216/231
94 A-    64  24   4  3  0   6  13   375/429/531
   A    189  36   9  4  1  11  71   190/252/296
95 A    447 113  15  5  3  33 101   253/314/329
96 A+   433 112  18  4  2  48 107   259/343/333
97 A+   112  28   5  0  0  25  28   250/391/295
   A     69  15   2  0  1   8  20   217/317/290

Elinton Jasco: 23-5/11/75; NDFA '93, San Pedro de Macoris,DR (HS)
2B, R-R, 5-10 150

Jasco came from the Cubs organization apparently traded in exchange for Kary Bridges (in early April). He looks to be an interesting prospect. He's put up a fairly high Batting Average with a somewhat above average BB rate and he steals a lot of bases. In short, thus far he looks like an improved version of Tony Womack. I don't know anything about his Defense.
          AB   H  2B 3B HR  BB  SO  SB  CS   BA/OBP/SLG
93  DSL          ?????
94  R    241  61   9  2  1  29  60  37  20  253/336/320
95  R    124  47   6  3  1  16  18  29   9  379/445/500
    A     25   8   2  0  0   0   5   2   0  320/320/400
96  A    464 136  11  7  1  62  97  48  14  293/381/353
97  A+   281  94  10  4  1  31  61  32  11  335/404/409

Augusta A (full season, low)
Stan Schreiber: 22-9/8/75; #26 '94; Kimberly HS (WI)
2B/SS, R-R, 5-10 175
Schreiber just finished his 2nd straight season at Augusta without much improvement. He started out the year hitting decently, but really faded in the 2nd half. Other than being able to take a walk, he has poor offensive skills. For '98, perhaps he could be a backup utility IF at Lynchburg, but more likely he'll be gone from the system.
         AB   H  2B 3B HR  BB  SO    BA/OBP/SLG
94 GCL  103  28   1  1  0  10  27   272/353/301
95 A-     7   2   0  2  0   1   2   286/375/857
   GCL  128  33   1  2  0  21  23   258/368/297
96 A    367  83  10  5  1  52  96   226/334/289
97 A    345  74  10  1  1  65  83   215/341/258

Erie A- (short season)
Terrance Freeman: 23-1/24/75; #31 (D&F) '94 (Oakland); Edison CC (FL)
2B, S-R, 5-9 165
Freeman was picked up after being let go by the A's; at that point, he hadn't shown an ability to hit for average and was squeezed out by an excess of prospects in the A's system. This season in Erie he showed an ability to hit for average, while also increasing his BB rate. He also has been fairly good on the basepaths; in '96, he stole 21 bases in 28 attempts; in '97, he stole 46 bases in 57 attempts. He's old to have been playing at short season A, but his numbers were so good that he put himself on the prospect map and played in the Hawaii Winter League this offseason. He is likely to begin the year at Augusta in '98, though I hope they promote him more aggressively and start him in Lynchburg.
         AB   H  2B 3B HR  BB  SO    BA/OBP/SLG
95 R     95  23   0  1  0  10  25   242/333/263
96 A-   167  39   5  1  0  23  29   234/344/275
97 A-   217  68   9  2  2  38  38   313/438/401
   HAW   80  16   2  0  1   8  11   200/297/263

Gulf Coast (Rookie League)
Oliver Mejias: 21-9/21/76; FA 9/94; Venezuela
2B/SS, S-R, 6-1 180
A switch hitting middle infielder from Venezuela, Mejias had a pretty good season in Rookie ball. However, he's a little old for that level, and he was below average at drawing BB. On the other hand, his 12 doubles suggest that he may develop some power in the future. He will probably play in Erie in '98, though Augusta is not out of the question.
         AB   H  2B 3B HR  BB  SO    BA/OBP/SLG
95 DSL  179  56   9  3  0  18  27   313/376/397
96 DSL  229  53   7  1  1  27  34   231/313/284
97 R    157  46  12  1  0   7  26   293/319/382

Projections:

Bucs: Womack
Nashville: Hermansen Bridges
Carolina: Robinson
Lynchburg: Figueroa Swafford
Augusta: Freeman
Erie: Mejias
Gulf Coast League: draft pick
Robinson was released in early April. Swafford was released in the off season and headed to the independent Western League.


Is there something here you like, that needs to be changed,
or would you like to see something that is not included?
Send me an
e-mail

Take a look back at the 1997 and 1996 Scouting Reports

Go back to Mark's 1998 Scouting Report front page

Go back to Glenn's Pirates Page

Go back to Glenn's Home Page