Pirate 1999 Scouting Report - First Basemen

Last Updated 15 January 1999

On November 22, 1998, Mark Jareb (lshark@akula.com) posted the following to the Pirate e-mail list. I have edited it and included it here with his permission.


Index: | Pirates | Nashville | Altoona | Lynchburg | Hickory | Williamsport | GCL | Projections |
Pirates
Kevin Young: 29-6/16/69; #7 '90, Southern Miss.
1B, R-R, 6-2 219
Kevin solidified his starting role on the Bucs by playing every day and displaying the main power bat on the 1998 team. Offensively though, he was below average, relative to other 1Bmen in the league. Compared to '97, he hit very similarly vs. RHP while cooling off considerably vs. LHP. If '98 constituted a slump against lefties he may put up slightly better numbers in '99. He can play 3B and the corner OF slots more than adequately (which raises his value as a future utility man), but has remained at 1B thus far becuase of his stellar defense there. The consensus of observers is that while he's good at fielding grounders, he's particularly excelled at making plays on errant throws. Still, if the Bucs were to find a very good hitting LH 1B, Young would probably be moved to another position. He's signed only through '99 (at $2M), so his future with the Bucs in the next millennium is uncertain. It appears that he'll be the starting 1B once again in '99.
Previous Young reports
         AB   H  2B 3B HR  BB  SO  SB CS    BA/OBP/SLG  vs LHP      vs RHP
90 A-   238  58  16  2  5  31  36  10      244/331/391
91 A+   201  63  12  4  6  20  34   3  -   313/376/502
   AA   263  90  19  6  3  15  38   9  -   342/378/494
   AAA    9   2   1  0  0   0   0   1  -   222/222/333
92 AAA  490 154  29  6  8  67  67  18 12   314/397/447
   PIT    7   4   0  0  0   2   0   1  0   571/667/571
93 PIT  449 106  24  3  6  36  82   2  2   236/300/343
94 AAA  228  63  14  5  5  15  45   6  2   276/321/447  275/         277/
   PIT  122  25   7  2  1   8  34   0  2   205/258/320
95 AAA  163  58  23  1  8  15  21   6  3   356/410/656
   PIT  181  42   9  0  6   8  53   1  3   232/268/381  156/191/313  274/310/419
96 AAA  186  57  11  1 13  12  41   3  0   306/358/586
   K.C  132  32   6  0  8  11  32   3  3   242/301/470  322/392/632  089/109/156
97 PIT  333 100  18  3 18  16  89  11  2   300/332/535  360/376/605  279/317/510
98 PIT  592 160  40  2 27  44 127  15  7   270/328/481  248/302/467  277/335/486

There are several options for a MLB back-up at first base for the Bucs: Brant Brown, Ed Sprague, Doug Strange, Freddy Garcia are all 1B-backup possibilities that are listed in other areas of the scouting report.


Nashville AAA
Ron Wright: 23-1/21/76; #7 '94 (Atlanta), Kennewick,WA(HS)
1B, R-R, 6-0 215
Back injury problems derailed Wright's '98 season and will likely play a big role in '99 as well. After trying to rest and rehabilitate his back, Wright had a brief stint in Bradenton, but finally decided to undergo surgery on September 1. He's expected to be ready for spring training in '99, though I'm surmising it'll be a while longer before he's 100% at the plate. His biggest asset is his power and recovery from his back injury may temporarily rob him of that to some extent. Hopefully, he'll regain the patience at the plate he demonstrated prior to '97. His limited '98 numbers suggest he may have been going back to that strategy of hitting. I expect he'll be in AAA once again in '99, splitting the 1B/DH duties with some veteran LH minor leaguer.
Previous Wright reports
         AB   H  2B 3B HR  BB  SO  SB CS    BA/OBP/SLG  vs LHP      vs RHP
94  R   169  29   9  0  1  10  21   1  0   172/218/243
95  A   527 143  23  1 32  62 118   2  0   271/348/501
96  A+  240  66  15  2 20  37  71   1  0   275/363/604
    AA  246  61  11  1 16  40  80   1  1   248/354/496
    MEX  41   6   1  0  3   4  13   0  0   146/234/390
97  AAA 336 102  31  0 16  24  81   0  2   304/348/539  316/         299/
    AFL 157  34   7  1 11  15  67   0  0   214/285/484
98  AAA  56  12   3  0  0   9  18   0  0   214/328/268  333/412/333  171/292/244
    R    10   6   0  0  2   2   0   0  0   600/615/1.200

Domingo Martinez: 31-8/4/67; NDFA '84(TOR); Santo Domingo, DR
1B/DH, R-R, 6-2 215

Martinez made his professional debut in the Toronto organization in 1985 and made his big-league debut with the Blue Jays in 1992. In 15 major league games in 1992-93, he hit .409 (9-for-22) with two homers and six RBI. The last two seasons, Martinez has played for the Seibu Lions of the Japanese Pacific League and hit 30 HRs or more each year. Seibu won its league title both years. In 133 games last year, he hit .283 with 30 home runs and 95 RBI. In 1997, Martinez ranked third in the league with 31 homers and second with 108 RBI while hitting .305. Defensively he was considered poor in Japan, such that he primarily was a DH. He's a dark horse with a slim shot at making the Pirates club as one of the primary pinch-hitters/backup 1Bman. This winter, he was signed as a minor league free agent by the Bucs and invited to spring training. Most likely he starts the year at Nashville splitting time Ivan Cruz at 1B/DH until Ron Wright is healthy. Then, either he or Ivan Cruz will be loaned to the Mexico City Red Devils as their 1Bman.
         AB   H  2B 3B HR  BB  SO  SB CS    BA/OBP/SLG  vs LHP      vs RHP
85-90 AA and lower
91 AAA
92 AAA
   MLB
93 AAA
   MLB
94 AAA
95 AAA
96 AAA  116  42   7  0  7                  362/
   MEX  413 132  22  4 18                  320/
97 JPN  488 149  24  1 31 61 103   3   -   305/384/549
98 JPN  491 139  16  0 30 59 101   4   -   283/361/503

Ivan Cruz was signed as a minor league free agent and invited to spring training.

Kevin Grijak played for the Bucs AAA/AA in '98, but was a minor league free agent and signed with the Dodgers in January.


Altoona AA
Tracy Sanders: 28-7/26/69; 58th Rd '90 (Indians); Limestone College
1B/DH/OF, L-R, 6-0 205
Tracy played a 2nd consecutive season at Carolina, again putting up an excellent OBP with good power. However, he did this again with a below average BA, so it's unlikely he'll be considered for a promotion to AAA. He's a minor league free agent and I doubt he'll be back with the Bucs. At this point he's likely to be a career minor leaguer, and my guess is that he'll likely sign with a team close to his residence. I hope some team is willing to give him a shot at even AAA, as I'd like to see what he'd do for a full season there.
Previous Sanders reports
         AB   H  2B 3B HR  BB  SO  SB CS    BA/OBP/SLG  vs LHP      vs RHP
90 R    178  50  12  1 10  33  36  10  3   281/397/528
   A+    32  14   3  3  0   7   6   1  1   438/538/719
91 A+   421 112  20  8 18  83  95   8  5   266/393/480
92 AA   381  92  11  3 21  77 113   3  6   241/371/451
93 AA   402 115  19  6 18  65  97  10  6   286/388/498
94 AA   275  66  20  4  8  60  88   8  6   240/376/429
95 AA    32   9   3  0  2   5  11   1  0   281/378/563
   AAA  110  25   6  0  4  34  34   3  1   227/426/391
96 AA   168  39  10  0  7  33  49   2  1   232/365/417
   IND  123  30   6  0  9  29  38   5  3   244/396/512
97 AA   376 102  23  1 21  74  88   7  6   271/397/505
98 AA   342  80  18  2 22  97  86   3  4   234/404/491  167/317/303  250/425/529

Eddy Furniss: 23-9/18/75; #4 '98; LSU
1B, L-L, 6-4 220

Eddy began his professional career in an amazing fashion, utterly destroying the pitching in the SAL. However, he seemed to hit a slump or was overmatched as soon as he was promoted to AA. Though he was still unable to find his stroke when sent back to Lynchburg, he still showed a good BB rate and some power. It's very early in his pro career but I really like the indications of his ability to get on base and hit for power. He could begin '99 in Lynchburg though a strong spring training could put him at AA Altoona.
Previous Furniss reports
         AB   H  2B 3B HR  BB  SO  SB CS    BA/OBP/SLG  vs LHP      vs RHP
95NCAA  215  70  14  1  9  15  44   2  -   326/370*/526
96NCAA  238  89  21  1 26  46  43   1  -   374/567*/798
97NCAA  259  98  25  0 17  58  56   0  3   378/491/672
98NCAA  236  95  27  3 28  72  40   0  3   403/545/898
98 A     86  40   7  0  9  24  20   1  1   465/571/860
   AA    44   6   1  0  0   4  13   0  0   136/200/159  167/167/167 125/211/156
   A+   109  21   7  0  2  17  38   1  0   193/305/312

Mark Farris played some 1B at Carolina last year, but you'll find his complete report with the 3Bmen. I expect he'll play mainly 1B at Altoona in '99.


Lynchburg A+ (full season, high)
Morgan Walker: 24-8/7/74; #23 '96; Lamar U. (TX)
1B/OF/DH, R-L, 6-3 215
Morgan has hit well with pretty good power every year as a pro so far. His poor BB rate, though, hinders his ability to become an above average offensive player (considering he's a 1Bman). He did play some Outfield this past season at Lynchburg, but defense is not his strong suit. His play at AA Altoona in '99 should be very telling as to whether he has a future in the majors.
Previous Walker reports
         AB   H  2B 3B HR  BB  SO  SB CS    BA/OBP/SLG  vs LHP      vs RHP
96 A    253  76  15  1  8  18  57   5  1   300/349/462
97 A+    89  24   6  0  3   6  19   0  0   270/316/438
   A    295  81  17  2 14  17  70   3  2   275/318/488
98 A+   373 111  24  0 14  22  92   1  0   298/334/475

Hickory A (full season, low)
Carlos Rivera: 21-6/10/78; #10 '96; Academia Adventista (PR)
1B, L-L, 6-1 220
Rivera did see a little time in Lynchburg, but again played most of the year in Augusta putting up similar numbers to '97. He's a very aggressive hitter which I think hurts him in the long run. If he went deeper into the count, I think his power as well as his OBP would increase. Plus, given his relatively low K rate, I think he'd still get the bat on the ball often enough to maintain a good BA. He's still relatively young, so he might find himself back in the SAL at Hickory. I think it's more likely he starts '99 in Lynchburg somehow splitting time with Furniss and/or Lankford.
Previous Rivera reports
         AB   H  2B 3B HR  BB  SO  SB CS    BA/OBP/SLG  vs LHP      vs RHP
96 R    183  52   8  3  3  15  22   1  1   284/338/410
97 A    415 113  16  5  9  19  82   4  1   272/316/400
98 A+   113  26   4  0  4   0  19   0  1   230/235/372
   A    316  90  17  1  5  11  46   3  5   285/318/392

Derrick Lankford: 24-9/21/74; #42 '97; Carson-Newman College
1B/OF, L-R, 6-4 220

Lankford now has put up 2 very good seasons, though again, he's old for the level at which he's played. His overall '98 numbers, which were good, even include a rather horrendous midseason slump. Clearly, he's a good power hitter with a good batting eye; hopefully, he'll be aggressively promoted to see what he can do at higher levels. There's a definite 1B logjam at Lynchburg with Rivera and Furniss. The most reasonable solution would be for Lankford to go to Altoona in '99, but I could easily see the Bucs signing a more experienced minor league Free Agent to fill the 1B/DH role there. He did play some OF in Augusta when Furniss was there, so Lankford might roam the outfield if he begins the year at Lynchburg.
Previous Lankford reports
         AB   H  2B 3B HR  BB  SO  SB CS    BA/OBP/SLG  vs LHP      vs RHP
97 A-   195  60  11  3 10  33  57   2  0   308/407/549
98 A    457 127  25  4 22  59 119   8  5   278/362/495

Williamsport A- (short season)
Keith Maxwell: 24-4/18/75; #21 '97; Florida A&M
1B/OF, R-R, 6-1 205
Maxwell played his 2nd season at Erie, and showed a much better stick. He's old for the level though. Nevertheless, the improved plate discipline and power increase are definitely positive steps. I expect he'll be the primary 1Bman at Hickory in '99.
Previous Maxwell reports
         AB   H  2B 3B HR  BB  SO  SB CS    BA/OBP/SLG  vs LHP      vs RHP
97 A-   134  28   3  1  6  10  38   1  1   209/292/381
98 A-   240  64  15  2  8  29  54   0  1   267/363/446

Gulf Coast (Rookie League)
Brian Cronk: ; #45 '98; Eastern New Mexico University
1B, B-R, 6-2 220
Cronk was drafted out of ENMU after his junior season. He had played Junior College ball at Glendale CC in Arizona. He showed a decent BB rate and power in rookie ball. He has a shot at making Hickory starting in '99, but Williamsport is not of the question either.
Previous Cronk reports
         AB   H  2B 3B HR  BB  SO  SB CS    BA/OBP/SLG  vs LHP      vs RHP
98 R     90  21   4  1  3  12  26   1  0   233/336/400

Eric Stanton: 21-8/30/77; #43 '98; U. of South Carolina
1B, R-R, 6-4 218

Stanton was drafted in the 15th round by the ChiSox in '95 out of high school, but opted to go to school at South Carolina. After an excellent sophomore year, he had a big slump (maybe due to a position switch from 1B to 3B) and seemed to carry that over to the minors. He doesn't have much plate discipline, but showed a little power. He probably will be in Williamsport in '99, though depending on his performance in instructional league and spring training, he could be in Hickory.
Previous Stanton reports
         AB   H  2B 3B HR  BB  SO  SB CS    BA/OBP/SLG  vs LHP      vs RHP
96NCAA  190  52   -  -  8   -   -   -  -   274/
97NCAA  226  78  18  0 14   -   -   3  -   345/---/611
98NCAA  240  59  11  1 16  20  73   2  7   246/315/500
98 R     89  17   7  0  1   7  19   0  0   191/250/303

Projections:

Bucs: Young
Nashville: Wright Martinez/Cruz
Altoona: Furniss/Lankford M Walker
Lynchburg: Rivera Lankford/Furniss
Hickory: Maxwell Cronk
Williamsport: Stanton
Gulf Coast League: draft pick


Is there something here you like, that needs to be changed,
or would you like to see something that is not included?
Send me an
e-mail

Take a look back at the 1998, the 1997, and 1996 Scouting Reports

Go back to Mark's 1999 Scouting Report front page

Go back to Glenn's Pirates Page